Saturday, October 11, 2025

Review of A Brief History of Intelligence: Evolution, AI, and the Five Breakthroughs That Made Our Brains by Max Bennett

This book review was written by Eugene Kernes   

Book can be found in: 
Genre = Science
Book Club Event = Book List (11/15/2025)



Watch Short Review


Excerpts

“But the sheer number of connections is only one aspect of what makes the brain complex; even if we mapped the wiring of each neuron we would still be far from understanding how the brain works.  Unlike the electrical connections in your computer, where wires all communicate using the same signal – electrons – across each of these neural connections, hundreds of different chemicals are passed, each with completely different effects.  The simple fact that two neurons connect to each other tells us little about what they are communicating.  And worst of all, these connections themselves are in a constant state of change, with some neurons branching out and forming new connections, while others are retracting and removing old ones.  Altogether, this makes reverse engineering how the brain works an ungodly task.” – Max Bennett, Introduction, Page 14


“Species fall into different survival niches, each of which optimizes for different things.  Many niches – in fact, most niches – are better served by smaller and simpler brains (or no brains at all).  Big-brained apes are the result of a different survival strategy than that of worms, bacteria, or butterflies.  But none are “better.”  In the eyes of evolution, the hierarchy has only two rungs: on one, there are those that survived, and on the other, those that did not.” – Max Bennett, Introduction, Page 23

 

“This was the breakthrough of steering.  It turns out that to successfully navigate in the complicated world of the ocean floor, you don’t actually need an understanding of that two-dimensional world.  You don’t need an understanding of where you are, where food is, what paths you might have to take, how long it might take, or really anything meaningful about the world.  All you need is a brain that steers a bilateral body toward increasing food smells and away from decreasing food smells.” – Max Bennett, Chapter 2: The Birth of Good and Bad, Page 45


Review

Is This An Overview?

The complexity of the brain was developed over time through the process of evolution.  Different species have their own survival strategies, their own evolutionary niches, which incorporate various brain sizes, of various complexity, or no brain at all.  What led to human intelligence was a series of five breakthroughs.  The five breakthroughs were steering, reinforcing, simulating, mentalizing, and speaking.  The development of Artificial Intelligence, is based on how people have come to understand the brain. 

 

Intelligence first breakthrough was steering.  All a brain needed to do was steer a body toward increasing food smells, and away from decreasing food smells.  Steering also enabled the brain to avoid dangers.  Steering developed preferences, and emotions.  Intelligence second breakthrough was reinforcing.  Enabled a brain to explore the surroundings, to be curious, and learn what could work or not work.  Intelligence third breakthrough was simulating.  Which is the ability to make predictions, that enabled planning, and to direct attention.  Intelligence fourth breakthrough was mentalizing.  Learning behaviors based on observations of others.  Learning created demand for teaching, which is effective only when someone has a theory of mind, a theory about what information the other has.  Intelligence fifth breakthrough was speaking.  Speaking enabled the accumulation of information. 

 

Caveats?

While there is a lot of content meant for a general audience, there is some content that requires a more technical background.  


Questions to Consider while Reading the Book

•What is the raison d’etre of the book?  For what purpose did the author write the book?  Why do people read this book?
•What are some limitations of the book?
•To whom would you suggest this book?
•How has A.I. changed? 
•What makes the functioning of the brain difficult to understand? 
•How are human brains compared to other brains? 
•What are the layers of the brain? 
•What are evolutionary niches?  
•What is DNA?
•What are cyanobacteria? 
•What was the Oxygen Holocaust?  
•How do fungi survive? 
•What information do neurons send?
•What are bilaterians? 
•What is breakthrough #1, Steering?
•What is valance?
•What are deaths of despair? 
•What is the credit assignment problem?
•What is breakthrough #2, Reinforcing?
•How to learn? 
•What is breakthrough #3, Simulating?
•How does being warm-blooded effect intelligence? 
•What is breakthrough #4, Mentalizing?
•How to teach?
•What is breakthrough #5, Speaking?
•Where is the language organ?


Book Details
Edition:                  First Edition
Publisher:               HarperCollins Publishers
Edition ISBN:         9780063286368
Pages to read:          312
Publication:             2023
1st Edition:              2023
Format:                    eBook 

Ratings out of 5:
Readability    4
Content          3
Overall          3









Saturday, October 4, 2025

Review of The Big Picture: On the Origins of Life, Meaning, and the Universe Itself by Sean Carroll

This book review was written by Eugene Kernes   

Book can be found in: 
Genre = Science
Book Club Event = Book List (10/25/2025)
Intriguing Connections = 1) What Makes Science A Science?, 2) The Style of Math


Watch Short Review

Excerpts

“The pressing, human questions we have about our lives depend directly on our attitudes toward the universe at a deeper level.  For many people, those attitudes are adopted rather informally from the surrounding culture, rather than arising out of rigorous personal reflection.  Each new generation of people doesn’t invent the rules of living from scratch; we inherit ideas and values that have evolved over vast stretches of time.  At the moment, the dominant image of the world remains one in which human life is cosmically special and significant, something more than mere matter in motion.  We need to do better at reconciling how we talk about life’s meaning with what we know about the scientific image of our universe.”– Sean Carroll, Chapter 1: The Fundamental Nature of Reality, Page 25



“Physics is, by far, the simplest science.  It doesn’t seem that way, because we know so much about it, and the required knowledge often seems esoteric and technical.  But it is blessed by this amazing feature: we can very often make ludicrous simplifications – frictionless surfaces, perfectly spherical bodies – ignoring all manner of ancillary effects, and nevertheless get results that are unreasonably good.  For most interesting problems in other sciences, from biology to psychology to economics, if you modeled one tiny aspect of a system while pretending all the others didn’t exist, you would just end up getting nonsense.  (Which doesn’t stop people from trying.)” – Sean Carroll, Chapter 3: The World Moves by Itself, Page 35


“Coarse-graining goes one way – from microscopic to macroscopic – but not the other way.  You can’t discover the properties of the microscopic theory just from knowing the macroscopic theory.  Indeed, emergent theories can be multiply realizable: there can, in principle, be many distinct microscopic theories that are incompatible with one another but compatible with the same emergent description.  You can understand the air as a fluid without knowing anything about its molecular composition, or even if there is a description in terms of particles at all.” – Sean Carroll, Chapter 12: Reality Emerges, Page 108


Review

Is This An Overview?

What people think about the universe depends on their culture, that has been updated over generations.  Updated with a scientific understanding.  Much like how planets hold themselves together through a self-reinforcing pattern, beliefs hold themselves together in a mutual epistemological force.  People have their biases, which can cause them to seek to confirm their views, rather than seek a better understanding.  People can see causes and reasons in events which occurred by random chance.  Science is based on empiricism, deriving knowledge from experiences.  But there are limits to experiences which creates a need to constantly update beliefs.  Within the scientific fields, physics is simple, for within physics, various simplifications of reality still obtain quality results.  In other sciences, social sciences, simplifications tend to create havoc with the results. 

 

Caveats?

There are a variety of different ideas presented in the book which explain features of reality, and ways to think about reality.  The topics are given more than a survey understanding, but that might not be enough to understand the complexity of the topics.  Background information into fields of physics, mathematics, and others is not necessary but can aid in understanding the topics.  Topic interest depends on the reader. 

 


Questions to Consider while Reading the Book

•What is the raison d’etre of the book?  For what purpose did the author write the book?  Why do people read this book?
•What are some limitations of the book?
•To whom would you suggest this book?
•Can people live forever?
•What is ontology?
•How do people think about the universe? 
•What is naturalism?
•What were Galileo Galilei’s insight?
•What is the difference between physics and social sciences?  
•What is Laplace’s Demon?
•What is Chaos Theory?
•What is quantum mechanics? 
•What do people think of random chance? 
•What is the Principle of Sufficient Reason?
•What is the difference between the Bing Bang model, and the Big Bang? 
•What does the future of the universe look like?
•How does time function?
•What is Bayesian philosophy?
•What is coarse-graining? 
•What are the different types of emergences? 
•What is a stable set of beliefs? 
•What is cognitive dissonance? 
•What is confirmation bias?  
•What is the difference between mathematical proofs and legal sufficient evidence? 
•What is empiricism?  
•How does evolution function?
•What are memories? 
•What is consciousness? 
•What is panpsychism? 
•What is Gobel’s Incompleteness Theorem?
•Is there free will?
•What are the Ten Commandments? 

Book Details
Publisher:               Dutton [Penguin Random House]
Edition ISBN:         9780698409767
Pages to read:          436
Publication:             2017
1st Edition:              2016
Format:                    eBook 

Ratings out of 5:
Readability    3
Content          3
Overall          3