Monday, October 26, 2026

Review of Linchpin: Are You Indispensable? by Seth Godin

This book review was written by Eugene Kernes   

Book can be found in: 


Watch Short Review

Excerpts

“You weren’t born to be a cog in the giant industrial machine.  You were trained to become a cog.  |  There’s an alternative available to you.  Becoming a linchpin is a stepwise process, a path in which you develop the attributes that make you indispensable.  You can train yourself to matter.  The first step is the most difficult, the step where you acknowledge that this is a skill, and like all skills, you can (and will) get better at it.  Every day, if you focus on the gifts, art, and connections that characterize the linchpin, you’ll become a little more indispensable.” – Seth Godin, Introduction, Page 6


“Here’s the problem, which you’ve already guessed.  If you make your business possible to replicate, you’re not going to be the one to replicate it.  Others will.  If you build a business filled with rules and procedures that are designed to allow you to hire cheap people, you will have to produce a product without humanity or personalization or connection.  Which means you’ll have to lower your prices to compete.  Which leads to a race to the bottom.  |  Indispensable businesses race to the top instead.” – Seth Godin, The New World of Work, Page 11


“When your organization becomes more human, more remarkable, faster on its feet, and more likely to connect with customers, it becomes indispensable.  The very thing that made your employee a linchpin makes YOU a linchpin.  An organization of indispensable people doing important work is remarkable, profitable, and indispensable in and of itself.” – Seth Godin, Thinking About Your Choice, Page 35-36


Review

Is This An Overview?

People are trained and educated to be cogs.  Cogs are dispensable people.  Cogs exchange their thinking ability for an instruction manual, and do not take responsibility for decisions.  Linchpins are indispensable people who make a difference.  A linchpin is not labor or management.  A linchpin is someone who can figure out how to make valuable decisions that enable everything to happen.  Linchpin’s decisions are creative, passionate, have emotional work, lead others, and make human connections.  Everyone has the capacity to learn to develop the skills to become indispensable.

 

While cogs can be mistreated, because cogs are replaceable.  Linchpins have to be treated better because linchpins cannot be readily replaced.  For manages, what makes employees linchpins, makes the manager and organization a linchpin.  For an organization that has indispensable people, develop products that are indispensable.

 

Caveats?

This book is marketing what is known as the culture of innovation, that everyone can contribute to the decision making process.  Innovation is needed, but there are limits to the culture of innovation which are based on scarcities such as of time, resources, and attention.  People already spend their time working, and businesses are meant for efficient organization. 

 

This book is primarily a motivation book, in trying to get everyone to become a linchpin.  The explanation method is to share examples of other people’s work, or abstract claims about what linchpins can do.  To better understand various characteristics of what makes a linchpin, such as the emotional work, would require more research from books more capable on those subjects. 

 

Although education has problems, the attacks on education are counterproductive.  Education can make people cogs, but education can also enable people to figure out how to improve the ideas and systems that people care about.  What it takes is for people to want to learn beyond what an educational system provides. 

 

Having a system filled with indispensable people is fragile.  Should a single person leave, there could be vast negative consequences for the continuation of the business.  Cogs might not be as productive, but cogs can be replaced without breaking a system that is working.  The initially indispensable people should train and educate others to become better, but that would also result in the indispensable people becoming dispensable. 

 


Questions to Consider while Reading the Book

•What is the raison d’etre of the book?  For what purpose did the author write the book?  Why do people read this book?
•What are some limitations of the book?
•To whom would you suggest this book?
•What is a linchpin? 
•What is a cog?
•What is the power of a gift?
•What are indispensable businesses? 
•What is the value of mass production? 
•What is the value of an education?
•How does a linchpin get treated?
•What is the limit of depth of knowledge? 
•What is emotional labor?
•Who are artists?
•What does it mean to ship? 

Book Details
Publisher:               Portfolio [Penguin Group]
Edition ISBN:         9781591843160
Pages to read:          240
Publication:             2010
1st Edition:              2010
Format:                    Hardcover 

Ratings out of 5:
Readability    5
Content          3
Overall          3